Ford Ranger vs Toyota Tacoma: The Ultimate Mid-Size Truck Showdown

Introduction

When it comes to mid-size trucks, the Ford Ranger and Toyota Tacoma are two of the most popular choices on the market. Both vehicles offer a blend of rugged capability, modern technology, and everyday practicality. But which one truly stands out? In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll dive deep into the performance, features, and value of these two trucks to help you decide which one is the best fit for your needs.

2022 Alfa Romeo Giulia

$26906

Gas

2054 mi

Good Deal  

0 (5)

2024 Bentley Bentayga

$252097

Gas

47 mi

Fair Deal  

0 (5)

2016 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Sport 4WD

$25900

Gas

73215 mi

Good Deal  

0 (5)

See More

On-Road Performance: Steering and Handling

The Ford Ranger and Toyota Tacoma offer distinct driving experiences on paved roads. The Tacoma’s steering has been a point of contention for many drivers. At low speeds, the steering feels unnecessarily heavy, while at higher speeds, it becomes overly light, leading to a vague and less confident driving experience, especially on winding mountain roads.

--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

In contrast, the Ranger shines with its responsive and well-balanced steering. The truck’s Sport mode, accessible via the tap-up/tap-down shifter, enhances throttle response and makes merging onto highways or navigating tight corners a breeze. The Ranger’s firm front-end handling and flat cornering further solidify its position as the more enjoyable truck to drive on paved roads.

2018 Acura ILX

$64030

Gas

45002 mi

Good Deal  

4 (5)

2023 Tesla Model Y

$37391

electric

15121 mi

Very Good Deal  

0 (5)

2016 Buick Cascada

$12243

Gas

77700 mi

Good Deal  

1 (5)

See More

Off-Road Capability: Which Truck Conquers the Trails?

When it comes to off-road performance, both trucks bring impressive features to the table. The Ranger’s 10-speed transmission and low-range gearing (2.72:1) give it an edge on rocky terrain and steep climbs. Its Trail Control system, which automates throttle and braking, is a standout feature, though it occasionally struggles to maintain consistent engine revs and braking modulation.

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

The Tacoma, equipped with its TRD Sport package, performs admirably off-road but falls short in comparison. Its 265/65R17 Firestone Destination tires, more suited for street driving, limit its grip on challenging terrain. However, the Tacoma’s rear axle articulation and predictable power output in low range make it a capable off-roader in its own right.

2018 Acura ILX

$64030

Gas

45002 mi

Good Deal  

4 (5)

2023 Tesla Model Y

$37391

electric

15121 mi

Very Good Deal  

0 (5)

2016 Buick Cascada

$12243

Gas

77700 mi

Good Deal  

1 (5)

See More

Payload and Towing: Which Truck Carries More?

Payload capacity is a critical factor for truck buyers, and here the Ranger takes a significant lead. With a maximum payload rating of 1,860 pounds, the Ranger outperforms the Tacoma’s 1,060 pounds. This difference is largely due to the Ranger’s lightweight aluminum construction, which includes doors, hood, and tailgate.

--SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

In terms of towing, the Ranger also outshines the Tacoma, boasting a maximum towing capacity of 7,500 pounds compared to the Tacoma’s 6,400 pounds. However, the Tacoma’s V-6 engine feels less strained under heavy loads, offering a smoother driving experience when fully loaded.

--FOURTH CAR LIST HERE--

Fuel Efficiency: Which Truck Sips Fuel Wisely?

Fuel economy is another area where these trucks are closely matched. Despite the Ranger’s turbocharged four-cylinder engine and 10-speed transmission, it fell slightly short of its EPA-estimated fuel economy during real-world testing. The Tacoma’s 3.5-liter V-6, on the other hand, delivered an impressive 21.4 mpg average, edging out the Ranger’s 21.3 mpg.

--THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

It’s worth noting that the Tacoma’s fuel efficiency can drop significantly when driven aggressively, especially with the ECT Power mode engaged. For those prioritizing fuel economy, the Tacoma is the better choice, but the Ranger’s performance-oriented driving experience may justify its slightly higher fuel consumption.

Bed Technology: Practicality and Innovation

The Tacoma’s composite bed offers several advantages, including scratch resistance and built-in storage compartments. It also features a 400-watt three-prong outlet, perfect for powering tools or appliances on the go. The lower load-in height and damped tailgate further enhance its practicality.

The Ranger’s steel bed is durable and features three strong tie-down points, but it lacks the Tacoma’s innovative storage solutions. However, the Ranger’s lightweight aluminum tailgate is easier to open and close, making it a user-friendly option for daily use.

--FIFTH CAR LIST HERE--

Interior Quality: Comfort and Modernity

Inside the cabin, the Ranger takes the lead with its modern design and premium materials. The Lariat trim offers soft-touch surfaces, ample storage, and a large touchscreen infotainment system. The front seats are more comfortable and adjustable, addressing one of the Tacoma’s key shortcomings: the lack of height adjustment for the driver’s seat.

The Tacoma’s interior, while rugged and functional, feels dated in comparison. Hard plastics dominate the cabin, and the lack of rear-seat vents and charging ports is a notable drawback. However, the Tacoma’s wireless charging pad is a welcome feature that the Ranger lacks.

--BOTTOM ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Technology: Connectivity and Infotainment

The Ranger’s technology suite is more advanced, featuring a multicolored instrument cluster display, an intuitive Sync 3 infotainment system, and support for Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. The truck also offers four USB ports and a household outlet, ensuring all devices stay charged.

The Tacoma’s smaller display screen and less user-friendly interface make it harder to access information and controls. While it does offer a wireless charging pad, the lack of connectivity options and slower response times put it at a disadvantage compared to the Ranger.

Safety Features: Peace of Mind on the Road

Both trucks come equipped with a comprehensive suite of safety features, including adaptive cruise control, lane-keep assist, forward collision warning, and blind-spot monitoring. The Ranger, however, integrates these features more seamlessly, with easier-to-use controls and a more responsive collision warning system.

The Tacoma’s safety features, while effective, feel less integrated and harder to adjust. The Ranger’s softer brake pedal also encourages earlier braking, enhancing overall safety during sudden stops.

Value: Which Truck Offers More Bang for Your Buck?

When it comes to value, the Tacoma’s lower price tag gives it an edge. At $40,670, it undercuts the Ranger Lariat’s $44,855 price by over $4,000. Despite this, the Ranger’s superior on-road performance, advanced technology, and higher payload capacity make it a compelling option for those willing to spend a bit more.

--SIXTH CAR LIST HERE--

Ultimately, the choice between these two trucks comes down to your priorities. If you value affordability and fuel efficiency, the Tacoma is the better choice. However, if you’re looking for a more modern, capable, and feature-rich truck, the Ranger is worth the extra investment.

Overall Winner: Ford Ranger

After evaluating all aspects of these two trucks, the Ford Ranger emerges as the clear winner. Its superior powertrain, modern interior, advanced technology, and impressive payload capacity make it the better choice for most buyers. While the Tacoma remains a strong contender, particularly for those on a budget, the Ranger’s overall performance and features set it apart in the mid-size truck segment.