Home > News & Blogs > 2019 Mid-Size SUV Comparison: Does the Nissan Murano Dominate?
2019 Mid-Size SUV Comparison: Does the Nissan Murano Dominate?
The Ultimate Midsize Luxury SUV Comparison: Finding Your Perfect Premium Ride
Key Takeaway: The Hyundai Santa Fe emerges as the top choice in our rigorous midsize luxury SUV comparison, offering exceptional value, smart technology integration, and family-friendly practicality - though competitors like the Honda Passport and Nissan Murano present compelling alternatives depending on your priorities.
Why Midsize Luxury SUVs Are Perfect for Modern Families
The midsize luxury SUV segment has become the sweet spot for discerning buyers who want premium features without the bulk of third-row vehicles. These sophisticated crossovers blend upscale appointments with everyday practicality, offering:
- Generous passenger and cargo space without excessive exterior dimensions
- Premium materials and advanced technology features
- Superior ride comfort and noise insulation compared to mainstream models
- Available all-wheel-drive systems for all-weather confidence
- Advanced safety systems as standard or available options
- --TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Our Comprehensive Testing Methodology
MotorVero's team of automotive experts subjected six leading midsize luxury SUVs to exhaustive evaluation across 17 critical categories:
Performance Metrics
- Acceleration and powertrain refinement
- Braking performance
- Handling and cornering stability
- Ride comfort and suspension tuning
- Noise, vibration, and harshness (NVH) levels
Practical Considerations
- Cargo capacity and storage solutions
- Seat comfort and ergonomics
- Visibility and driving position
- Child seat accommodation
- Fuel efficiency
Premium Features
- Interior material quality
- Technology and infotainment systems
- Advanced safety features
- Value for money
- Warranty coverage
-
The Contenders: Six Premium Midsize SUVs Compared
Our evaluation included the most compelling models in this competitive segment:
Model | Starting Price | Key Strength |
---|---|---|
Hyundai Santa Fe | $32,250 | Exceptional value proposition |
Honda Passport | $37,085 | Reliability and resale value |
Nissan Murano | $32,510 | Premium interior ambiance |
Chevrolet Blazer | $33,400 | Sporty styling |
Ford Edge | $36,075 | Technology integration |
Jeep Grand Cherokee | $36,395 | Off-road capability |
--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
And the Winner Is: Hyundai Santa Fe
After comprehensive testing, the redesigned Hyundai Santa Fe claimed victory by a narrow margin, dethroning our previous favorite, the Nissan Murano. The Santa Fe's triumph stems from its exceptional balance of virtues:
What Sets the Santa Fe Apart
- Unmatched Value: Premium features at mainstream prices with Hyundai's outstanding warranty
- Thoughtful Packaging: Clever storage solutions and generous cargo capacity (35.9 cu ft behind rear seats)
- Safety Leadership: Standard Hyundai SmartSense suite including forward collision avoidance and lane keeping assist
- User-Friendly Tech: Intuitive 8-inch touchscreen with physical controls for critical functions
- Family-Friendly Design: Easy-to-clean surfaces and wide rear door openings
Areas for Improvement
No vehicle is perfect, and the Santa Fe has room for growth:
- Underwhelming base engine performance
- Firm ride quality on larger wheel options
- Some hard plastics in lower cabin areas
- Limited powertrain options compared to rivals
-
Detailed Competitor Analysis
Honda Passport: The Worthy Challenger
Finishing just one point behind the Santa Fe, the Honda Passport presents a compelling alternative with different strengths:
- Pros: Legendary Honda reliability, superior resale value, spacious interior, confident handling
- Cons: Less luxurious interior materials, smaller sunroof, no hybrid option
- Best For: Buyers prioritizing long-term ownership costs and driving dynamics
Nissan Murano: The Comfort King
Our previous winner still shines in specific areas:
- Pros: Plush Zero Gravity seats, upscale cabin materials, distinctive styling
- Cons: Less cargo space than newer competitors, dated infotainment system
- Best For: Luxury seekers who prioritize comfort over utility
Other Notable Competitors
Chevrolet Blazer: Stands out with its coupe-like styling and available RS trim, but compromised rear visibility and cargo space.
Ford Edge: Tech lovers will appreciate the available 12-inch touchscreen and Co-Pilot360, though the interior feels less premium.
Jeep Grand Cherokee: The off-road specialist with available air suspension and legendary Trail Rated models, but poor fuel economy.
--SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Who Should Buy Which SUV?
Choosing the right midsize luxury SUV depends on your priorities:
- Value-Conscious Buyers: Hyundai Santa Fe - most features per dollar
- Tech Enthusiasts: Ford Edge - cutting-edge SYNC 4 system
- Comfort Seekers: Nissan Murano - premium seating experience
- Adventure Ready: Jeep Grand Cherokee - genuine off-road capability
- Resale Focused: Honda Passport - strongest predicted residual values
-
Emerging Trends in the Midsize Luxury SUV Segment
The segment continues evolving with several notable developments:
- Electrification: More hybrids and upcoming EV models like the Hyundai Ioniq 7
- Advanced Driver Aids: Increasingly sophisticated semi-autonomous systems
- Flexible Packaging: Adjustable cargo systems and modular interiors
- Digital Cockpits: Fully configurable instrument clusters and augmented reality HUDs
- --THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Making Your Decision: Test Drive Tips
Before visiting dealerships, consider these expert recommendations:
- Evaluate cargo space with your typical loads (strollers, golf bags, etc.)
- Test child seat installation if you have young children
- Experience the infotainment system while driving (not just parked)
- Drive on multiple road surfaces to assess ride quality
- Compare visibility at night and in rainy conditions
-
The Future of Midsize Luxury SUVs
As consumer preferences shift, manufacturers are responding with:
- More powerful yet efficient turbocharged and hybrid powertrains
- Lighter vehicle architectures improving performance and efficiency
- Enhanced connectivity with vehicle-to-everything (V2X) technology
- Sustainable materials in interior construction
- Subscription-based feature activation
Whether you choose the class-leading Hyundai Santa Fe or one of its worthy competitors, today's midsize luxury SUVs offer an unprecedented blend of sophistication, capability, and technology - making them ideal for discerning buyers who refuse to compromise.

motorverorachael
Last Updated On Apr, 16-2025