Nissan Maxima In-Depth Review: Assessing the Flagship Sedan's Strengths and Weaknesses
While many automakers are abandoning sedan segments in favor of SUVs, Nissan continues to refine its four-door lineup. The Maxima represents Nissan's flagship sedan offering, positioned as a premium sports sedan with V6 performance and luxury appointments. This comprehensive review examines what works well in the Maxima and where it falls short against formidable rivals like the Acura TLX and Toyota Avalon.
--FIRST CAR LIST HERE--
Nissan Maxima: Power and Performance
What We Appreciate About the Maxima
- Potent V6 Engine Performance: The 3.5-liter V6 delivers 300 horsepower with immediate throttle response, avoiding the turbo lag common in modern forced-induction engines. The power delivery builds linearly and provides confident passing power at highway speeds.
- Premium Interior Materials: Higher trims feature semi-aniline leather upholstery with double-stitching, aluminum accents, and padded surfaces that create a convincing luxury atmosphere. The Platinum Reserve Package elevates materials beyond typical mainstream offerings.
- Distinctive Styling: Nissan's "4-Door Sports Car" philosophy results in aggressive exterior styling with a floating roof design, bold V-motion grille, and available 19-inch alloy wheels that give visual presence lacking in more conservative rivals.
--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Where the Maxima Falls Short
Compromises and Considerations
- Questionable Handling Dynamics: The firm suspension tuning doesn't translate to precise handling. Test drivers note progressive understeer in corners, requiring stability system intervention. The previous-generation Maxima felt more composed during aggressive driving.
- Outdated Technology Interface: The 8-inch touchscreen system suffers from laggy response times, particularly with the backup camera display. Android Auto connectivity issues and frozen navigation maps were frequently reported during testing.
- Compromised Interior Space: Front seat occupants face intrusive center console design and limited footwell space. Rear seat cushions are short on thigh support, and headroom becomes tight with the available panoramic moonroof.
- Premium Pricing Concerns: At nearly $44,000 for top trims, the Maxima approaches near-luxury territory where competitors offer more advanced driver aids, superior ride comfort, and more spacious interiors.
--SECOND CAR LIST HERE--
How the Maxima Compares to Key Rivals
When cross-shopping the Maxima against segment competitors, several alternatives merit consideration:
Acura TLX
The TLX offers available Super Handling All-Wheel Drive (SH-AWD), more advanced safety technology, and a quieter cabin. While the base 2.4L engine feels underpowered, the available 3.5L V6 provides comparable performance to the Maxima with better fuel economy.
Toyota Avalon
Toyota's flagship sedan delivers superior rear seat comfort, more standard safety features, and an available hybrid powertrain. The Avalon's ride quality surpasses the Maxima's firm tuning, though it lacks the Nissan's sporty pretensions.
Kia Stinger
As a hatchback alternative, the Stinger offers rear-wheel-drive dynamics, more cargo versatility, and available twin-turbo V6 power. Interior materials fall slightly short of the Maxima's top trims but the driving experience is more engaging.
--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Ownership Considerations
Prospective Maxima buyers should weigh several factors:
- Fuel Economy: The V6 returns an EPA-estimated 20 mpg city/30 highway, competitive for the segment but surpassed by turbo-four and hybrid alternatives
- Reliability History: Nissan's VQ-series V6 has proven durable, though some owners report transmission concerns with the CVT unit
- Resale Value: Depreciation outpaces luxury-branded competitors but remains stronger than many mainstream sedans
- Warranty Coverage: Nissan's 3-year/36,000-mile basic warranty matches most competitors, though some rivals offer longer powertrain coverage
--THIRD CAR LIST HERE--
Final Verdict
The Nissan Maxima presents an intriguing proposition with its powerful naturally aspirated V6 and upscale interior appointments in higher trims. However, compromises in handling precision, technology execution, and rear seat comfort prevent it from fully delivering on its "4-Door Sports Car" promise. Value-conscious buyers may prefer the more spacious and efficient Toyota Avalon, while driving enthusiasts might lean toward the Kia Stinger or Acura TLX. The Maxima ultimately serves buyers prioritizing distinctive styling and strong acceleration in a front-wheel-drive package, provided they can overlook its dynamic shortcomings at higher price points.
