Home > News & Blogs > 2025 Nissan Rogue Three-Peats as Motorvero's Best Compact SUV
2025 Nissan Rogue Three-Peats as Motorvero's Best Compact SUV
2025 Nissan Rogue: Three-Time Compact SUV Champion
For the third consecutive Cars.com Compact SUV Challenge, the Rogue outshines rivals with premium comfort, cutting-edge tech and exceptional versatility
The Unlikely Dynasty
Against all odds - including a redesigned Chevrolet Equinox and the long-awaited inclusion of Toyota's RAV4 Hybrid - Nissan's Rogue secured its third straight victory in our rigorous comparison testing. The 2025 Rogue Platinum dominated with:
$64030 Gas 45002 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$20000 Gas 243232 mi
Fair
Deal
0
(5)
$49092 Gas 0 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
2024 Acura MDX
BMW 2 Series
2024 Chrysler Pacifica
4 Category Wins
Front/rear seat comfort, user interface, and interior quality - all subjective categories where judges unanimously preferred the Rogue
2 Objective Victories
Best driver-assist tech (including exclusive ProPilot Assist 2.1) and top-tier child seat installation
Consistent Excellence
No bottom-tier finishes except fuel economy (still a respectable 30.8 MPG)
- Stef Schrader, News Editor
Winning by the Numbers
| Category | Rogue Score | Class Average | Closest Competitor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interior Quality | 27/30 | 19.7 | CX-5 (24) |
| Front Seat Comfort | 24/30 | 19.9 | CR-V (21) |
| Backseat Comfort | 24/30 | 18.6 | CR-V (22) |
| Real-World MPG | 30.8 | 32.1 | RAV4 Hybrid (37.9) |
| Driver-Assist Tech | 15/15 | 8.6 | Tucson (9) |
The Rogue's Secret Weapons
1. ProPilot Assist 2.1
The only hands-free driving system in the test proved remarkably capable during highway evaluations. Judges praised its:
- Smooth lane centering
- Predictable speed adjustments
- Easy engagement process
2. Quilted Leather Sanctuary
Nissan's premium interior treatment set new class benchmarks for:
- Seat comfort (best front & rear scores)
- Material quality (27/30 vs CX-5's 24)
- Rear amenities (still class-exclusive sunshades)
-
2024 Honda Prologue
$40948
electric
2943 mi
Very Good Deal
0 (5)
2017 Acura ILX
$64900
Gas
4600 mi
Good Deal
0 (5)
2019 Audi A4 Allroad
$34000
Gas
52215 mi
Good Deal
0 (5)
3. Google-Based Tech Suite
The 12.3" dual-screen setup impressed with:
- Crisp, responsive touch inputs
- Intuitive climate control buttons
- Wireless Apple CarPlay stability
The Price of Victory
At $48,330 as tested, the Rogue Platinum carried a significant premium over competitors:
- $5,835 more than CR-V Hybrid Sport Touring
- $10,400 more than base Forester Sport
- Nearly matches luxury brand entry pricing
- Brian Normile, Road Test Editor
Room for Improvement
Powertrain Refinement
The 201HP turbo-3 delivers adequate power but shows limitations:
- Noticeable vibration at high RPM
- Elevated highway noise
- CVT drone under hard acceleration
Ergonomic Quirks
Several judges noted:
- Unconventional gear selector
- Steering wheel thickness
- Climate button visibility
- --FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Efficiency Gap
While respectable for gas-only models, the 30.8 MPG:
- Trails CR-V Hybrid by 5.7 MPG
- Lags RAV4 Hybrid by 7.1 MPG
- Adds ~$300/year in fuel costs
The Verdict: Unmatched All-Around Excellence
The 2025 Nissan Rogue's three-peat victory proves that consistent execution across all categories outweighs standout performances in single areas. While competitors may beat it in specific metrics like fuel economy (RAV4) or handling (CX-5), the Rogue's combination of:
- Class-leading interior comfort
- Cutting-edge driver assistance
- Intuitive technology
- Premium material quality
makes it the most complete package in the compact SUV segment. For buyers who prioritize daily comfort and premium features over sporty dynamics or maximum efficiency, the Rogue Platinum remains in a league of its own - even at its elevated price point.
Who Should Consider Alternatives? Budget-focused shoppers (Forester), efficiency seekers (CR-V Hybrid), or driving enthusiasts (CX-5 Turbo) may find better value elsewhere.
Motorveroben
Last Updated On May, 29-2025