Mid-Size Truck Safety Showdown: Comprehensive IIHS Crash Test Analysis
When shopping for a mid-size pickup truck, safety should be a top priority alongside capability and comfort. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) conducts rigorous crash testing to evaluate vehicle safety, providing consumers with critical data to make informed purchasing decisions. Recent evaluations of crew-cab and extended-cab versions of popular mid-size trucks reveal significant variations in crash protection performance.
$72986 Gas 3 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
$81853 electric 0 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$50000 Petrol 63325 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
2024 Lexus GX 550
2024 Jaguar I-PACE
BMW 6 Series 640i Coupe RWD
Understanding IIHS Safety Ratings
The IIHS evaluates vehicles through five key crashworthiness tests, with additional consideration given to advanced safety features and headlight performance. Their rating tiers are:
--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
| Rating Level | Requirements | Current Mid-Size Trucks |
|---|---|---|
| Top Safety Pick+ | Good in all 5 crash tests, advanced/superior automatic emergency braking, good headlights | Honda Ridgeline (only mid-size truck) |
| Top Safety Pick | Good in all crash tests, advanced/superior automatic emergency braking | None currently |
| Good | Good in most crash tests | Colorado, Canyon, Tacoma (specific configurations) |
$48995 Gas 19096 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$20998 87523 mi mi
Fair
Deal
0
(5)
$19375 Gas 93184 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
|
Detailed Model-by-Model Breakdown
Chevrolet Colorado & GMC Canyon
These mechanically similar twins from General Motors showed configuration-dependent performance:
- Crew-cab versions: Earned Good ratings across all crash test categories
- Extended-cab versions: Dropped to Acceptable due to slightly higher risk of injury in side-impact tests
Toyota Tacoma
Toyota's popular midsize pickup demonstrated consistent performance:
- Both crew-cab and extended-cab configurations earned Good ratings
- Showed particularly strong performance in small overlap front tests
- --FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Nissan Frontier: Concerning Results
The aging Frontier platform (last redesigned in 2005) received Marginal ratings in both cab configurations, highlighting how outdated designs may compromise safety. Key concerns included:
- Excessive intrusion into the occupant compartment during side impacts
- Higher risk of leg injuries in frontal collisions
- Poor seat/head restraint geometry increasing whiplash risk
Why These Ratings Matter for Truck Buyers
Mid-size trucks are increasingly popular for both personal and commercial use, making their safety performance particularly important. Consider these factors when evaluating IIHS results:
$39651 electric 14310 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$19499 Gas 72889 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
$18495 Gas 83815 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
2023 Audi Q4 Sportback e-tron
2014 Cadillac ATS
2017 Buick Cascada
Real-World Protection
IIHS tests simulate severe but realistic crash scenarios that reflect common real-world collisions. Their small overlap front test, for example, replicates hitting a tree or pole with just 25% of the vehicle's front end - a challenging scenario that many older designs struggle with.
Advanced Safety Features
While crashworthiness is fundamental, modern safety depends heavily on collision avoidance technology. The Honda Ridgeline's Top Safety Pick+ rating demonstrates how combining good crash protection with superior automatic emergency braking creates the safest package.
--SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Cab Configuration Differences
The varying performance between crew-cab and extended-cab versions of the same truck model underscores that structural design differences between configurations can significantly impact safety. Always check ratings for your specific configuration.
How Mid-Size Trucks Compare to Full-Size Pickups
While this analysis focuses on mid-size trucks, it's worth noting how they compare to their larger counterparts:
- Weight advantage: Full-size trucks typically perform better in collisions with smaller vehicles due to their mass
- Structural differences: Some full-size trucks have more advanced crumple zones and cabin protection
- Technology parity: Many safety features are now available across both segments
However, mid-size trucks often offer better maneuverability and avoidance capabilities that can prevent accidents in the first place.
$48000 electric 18036 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$61488 diesel 54487 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$37520 Gas 52920 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
Tesla Model X 75D AWD
Mercedes-Benz SL-Class SL 450 RWD
2021 Lincoln Aviator
Future Outlook for Truck Safety
As consumer demand for safer vehicles grows and regulations tighten, manufacturers are investing heavily in improved safety technologies for trucks. Emerging trends include:
- Standard automatic emergency braking: Becoming common even on base models
- Improved structural designs: Better energy management in crashes
- Advanced materials: Increased use of high-strength steel and aluminum
- Connected safety systems: Vehicle-to-vehicle communication for collision avoidance
These advancements suggest that future mid-size truck models will likely achieve even higher safety ratings across all configurations.
--THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
