Home > News & Blogs > Top-Rated 2018 One-Ton Heavy-Duty Trucks Compared
Top-Rated 2018 One-Ton Heavy-Duty Trucks Compared
Heavy-Duty Truck Showdown: Silverado 3500 vs F-350 vs Ram 3500
Comprehensive comparison of America's toughest workhorses in real-world towing and hauling scenarios
While headlines often focus on six-figure heavy-duty trucks with every available luxury feature, many commercial buyers and serious haulers simply need uncompromising capability without unnecessary frills. We put three diesel-powered workhorses through exhaustive testing to determine which single-rear-wheel one-ton truck delivers the best combination of performance, efficiency, and value.
$64030 Gas 45002 mi
Very Good
Deal
4
(5)
$270257 Gas 36 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$64900 Gas 4600 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
2024 Acura MDX Type S
2024 Bentley Bentayga
2017 Acura ILX
Testing Methodology
Our evaluation team conducted 16 rigorous performance tests in Arizona's challenging desert terrain, combining empirical measurements with real-world driving assessments. Testing included:
- Acceleration with and without 13,000-pound gooseneck trailers
- Braking performance on paved and unpaved surfaces
- Davis Dam grade climb with maximum payload
- Fuel efficiency measurements under various loads
- Noise level comparisons at highway speeds
- Payload handling and stability assessments
- --TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Judges also scored each truck across 10 subjective categories including interior comfort, technology integration, visibility, and overall value proposition. The maximum possible score combined 1,600 points from empirical testing and 600 points from subjective evaluations.
3rd Place: Ram 3500 Laramie
As-tested price: $74,435
- Engine: 6.7L Cummins Turbo Diesel I6 (385 hp, 930 lb-ft)
- Transmission: Aisin 6-speed automatic
- Drivetrain: Part-time 4WD
- Rear Axle Ratio: 3.42:1
- Gooseneck Capacity: 16,730 lbs
- Observed MPG: 16.9 empty / 9.9 towing
The Ram 3500 impressed judges with its exceptional ride comfort and confident towing manners, but ultimately placed third due to disappointing acceleration and fuel economy results.
Strengths
- Best-in-test ride quality with supplemental air suspension
- Most stable trailer handling during panic stops
- Thoughtful interior storage solutions
- Premium interior materials and comfort features
Weaknesses
- Slowest acceleration in all test scenarios
- Poor fuel efficiency despite favorable gearing
- Excessive cabin noise at highway speeds
- Unrefined transmission behavior
2nd Place: Ford Super Duty F-350 Lariat
As-tested price: $74,470
- Engine: 6.7L Power Stroke Turbo Diesel V8 (450 hp, 935 lb-ft)
- Transmission: TorqShift 6-speed automatic
- Drivetrain: Part-time 4WD
- Rear Axle Ratio: 3.55:1
- Gooseneck Capacity: 20,600 lbs
- Observed MPG: 17.8 empty / 10.2 towing
Ford's technology-packed F-350 delivered class-leading towing specifications and innovative features, but exhibited concerning trailer instability that prevented it from claiming victory.
Strengths
- Industry-best 20,600 lb gooseneck rating
- Most comprehensive driver information system
- Excellent outward visibility
- Innovative bed features and lighting
Weaknesses
- Unsettled behavior with heavy trailers
- Poor braking stability without trailer brakes
- Uncomfortable seating position
- Cramped engine compartment
1st Place: Chevrolet Silverado 3500 High Country
As-tested price: $70,965
- Engine: 6.6L Duramax Turbo Diesel V8 (445 hp, 910 lb-ft)
- Transmission: Allison 1000 6-speed automatic
- Drivetrain: Part-time 4WD
- Rear Axle Ratio: 3.73:1
- Gooseneck Capacity: 17,200 lbs
- Observed MPG: 18.7 empty / 10.4 towing
$48995 Gas 19096 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$49092 Gas 0 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
$35860 20 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
2023 Acura MDX
2024 Chrysler Pacifica
MINI Cooper S 4-Door Hatchback FWD
The Silverado 3500 claimed victory through dominant performance metrics and impressive value, proving that an aging platform can still outshine newer competitors where it matters most.
Strengths
- Best acceleration in all test scenarios
- Class-leading fuel efficiency
- Quietest cabin at highway speeds
- $3,500+ price advantage over competitors
Weaknesses
- Outdated driver information displays
- Poor DEF system implementation
- Limited interior storage solutions
- Mediocre camera systems
Key Decision Factors for Buyers
Our testing revealed several critical considerations for commercial and heavy-duty truck buyers:
--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Towing Professionals
For operators regularly hauling near maximum capacities, the Ford F-350's class-leading 20,600 lb gooseneck rating warrants consideration despite its handling quirks. The Ram 3500's superior stability under heavy loads makes it ideal for those prioritizing trailer control.
Fuel-Conscious Fleets
The Silverado 3500's 18.7 mpg observed fuel economy represents significant long-term savings for high-mileage operations. Its 3.73 axle ratio provides optimal balance between acceleration and cruising efficiency.
Value-Oriented Buyers
Chevrolet's pricing strategy delivers more features per dollar, with the High Country trim undercutting similarly equipped competitors by thousands. The Silverado also benefits from lower maintenance costs associated with its proven powertrain.
$79999 electric 43 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$55278 Gas 0 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
$26906 Gas 2054 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
2023 Jaguar I-PACE
Toyota Grand Highlander
2022 Alfa Romeo Giulia
Emerging Heavy-Duty Truck Trends
Our evaluation highlighted several industry developments that will shape future heavy-duty truck designs:
- Integrated Trailer Systems: Ford's advanced trailer monitoring sets new expectations for connectivity
- Ride Refinement: Ram's supplemental air suspension demonstrates demand for car-like comfort
- Efficiency Focus: All manufacturers face increasing pressure to improve fuel economy
- Driver Assistance: Adaptive cruise and camera systems transition from luxury to expected features
Final Recommendations
For most heavy-duty truck buyers, the Chevrolet Silverado 3500 represents the best balance of capability, efficiency, and value. While it lacks some technological polish of its competitors, its superior performance in core truck functions makes it our top recommendation.
The Ram 3500 excels for buyers prioritizing interior comfort and towing refinement, while the Ford F-350 suits those needing maximum capacity and cutting-edge features. All three trucks demonstrate impressive capabilities that far exceed most owners' requirements, proving that today's one-ton pickups represent the most capable work vehicles ever produced.
--SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
motorvero013
Last Updated On May, 06-2025