Home > News & Blogs > 2017 Honda Accord V6 vs. 4-Cylinder: Which Model Should You Buy?

2017 Honda Accord V6 vs. 4-Cylinder: Which Model Should You Buy?

Honda Accord V6 vs. 4-Cylinder: Is the Upgrade Worth It? | MotorVero

Honda Accord V6 vs. 4-Cylinder: Performance, Value & Real-World Comparison

Honda Accord V6 vs 4-cylinder

When shopping for a mid-size sedan, engine choice significantly impacts both driving experience and long-term ownership costs. The Honda Accord offers two distinct powertrain options: an efficient 4-cylinder and a powerful V6. But is the performance upgrade worth the premium price? MotorVero conducted comprehensive testing to help you make an informed decision.

2020 Acura ILX Image
2020 Acura ILX

$22400

Gas

31702 mi

Good Deal   Good

5 (5)

2020 Lincoln Aviator Image
2020 Lincoln Aviator

$40843

Gas

25714 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)

2017 Cadillac ATS Image
2017 Cadillac ATS

$19565

Gas

26281 mi

Fair Deal   Fair

4 (5)


Understanding the Honda Accord Engine Options

The Honda Accord's engine lineup presents buyers with a classic choice between efficiency and performance:

  • 2.4L 4-cylinder engine: 185 horsepower, 181 lb-ft torque (standard across most trims)
  • 3.5L V6 engine: 278 horsepower, 252 lb-ft torque (available on higher trims)

Key Performance Differences at a Glance

Specification 4-Cylinder V6
0-60 mph Acceleration 7.6 seconds 5.8 seconds
EPA Combined MPG 30 mpg 25 mpg
Typical Price Difference $31,655 (EX-L Nav w/Sensing) $35,665 (Touring)

Acceleration & Driving Dynamics: V6 Dominates

Our performance testing revealed substantial differences between these two powertrains:

  • Straight-line acceleration: The V6 shaves nearly 2 seconds off the 0-60 time compared to the 4-cylinder
  • Passing power: 50-70 mph highway passing occurs 1.5 seconds quicker with the V6
  • Engine character: The V6 delivers smoother power delivery with less need for downshifting

"The V6 transforms the Accord's personality," noted our test driver. "Where the 4-cylinder feels competent, the V6 makes the Accord genuinely quick and more engaging to drive."

--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Fuel Economy Comparison: The 4-Cylinder's Advantage

During mixed driving conditions, we observed:

  • City driving: 4-cylinder averaged 26 mpg vs. V6's 21 mpg
  • Highway cruising: 4-cylinder achieved 35 mpg vs. V6's 30 mpg
  • Annual fuel cost difference: Approximately $300-$500 (15,000 miles/year)

Trim Level Considerations & Pricing Analysis

The V6 engine comes exclusively on higher trims, creating a significant price gap:

Feature 4-Cylinder EX-L V6 Touring
Base MSRP Difference $31,655 $35,665
Additional V6 Features - Adaptive dampers, premium audio, ventilated seats
Resale Value (3 years) 52% retained 55% retained

Who Should Choose the V6 Accord?

The V6 makes sense for drivers who:

When the 4-Cylinder Makes More Sense

Consider the base engine if you:

  • Primarily commute in stop-and-go traffic
  • Want to minimize fuel costs and environmental impact
  • Don't need the Touring trim's luxury features
  • Prefer a lighter front end for winter driving

Long-Term Ownership Considerations

Beyond initial pricing, consider these factors:

  • Maintenance costs: Comparable between engines
  • Insurance premiums: Typically 5-8% higher for V6 models
  • Real-world reliability: Both engines have excellent track records

Expert Verdict: Which Accord Should You Buy?

For most buyers, the 4-cylinder Accord delivers the best balance of efficiency, value and adequate performance. However, driving enthusiasts and those who frequently travel with full passenger loads will appreciate the V6's superior power - especially when paired with the Touring trim's premium features.

The $4,000 price premium buys you more than just acceleration - it transforms the Accord from competent commuter to genuine sport sedan. Whether that's worth the investment depends entirely on your priorities behind the wheel.

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Final Recommendation

Choose the 4-cylinder if: Value and efficiency are your top priorities

Upgrade to the V6 if: You crave performance and can utilize the Touring trim's luxury features

Compare All Accord Trims

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the V6 Accord being discontinued?

Honda has moved toward turbocharged 4-cylinder engines in recent model years, making existing V6 Accords particularly appealing to performance-oriented buyers.

Can you get a manual transmission with the V6?

Earlier Accord generations offered manual V6 models, but by this model year, the V6 was only available with an automatic transmission.

How does the V6 affect handling?

The additional front-end weight slightly changes the Accord's balance, though the Touring trim's adaptive dampers help compensate for this.

Toyota Grand Highlander Image
Toyota Grand Highlander

$55278

Gas

0 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)

Mercedes Benz EQE Image
Mercedes Benz EQE

$102310

electric

12 mi mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)

2016 Buick Cascada Image
2016 Buick Cascada

$12243

Gas

77700 mi

Good Deal   Good

1 (5)


proImg

motorvero013

Last Updated On Jun, 23-2025

Share Now: