2018 Honda Accord vs. Toyota Camry: The Ultimate Fuel Efficiency Showdown
The Great Midsize Sedan Rivalry Renewed
The 2018 model year marked a pivotal moment in automotive history as both the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry underwent comprehensive redesigns. While enthusiasts debated styling and tech features, practical buyers focused on one critical question: Which sedan delivers better fuel economy and lower operating costs?
$20000 Gas 243232 mi
Fair
Deal
0
(5)
$40843 Gas 25714 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
$134524 electric 445 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
BMW 2 Series
2020 Lincoln Aviator
2024 Tesla Cybertruck
At a time when national gas prices reached 3-year highs during the 2018 Thanksgiving season, understanding the true cost of ownership became essential for budget-conscious families comparing these two segment leaders.
EPA Fuel Economy: A Closer Look at the Numbers
While both vehicles promised improved efficiency over their predecessors, their approaches differed significantly:
2018 Honda Accord LX
- 30/38/33 mpg (city/highway/combined)
- 14.8-gallon fuel tank
- 1.5L Turbocharged 4-cylinder engine
2018 Toyota Camry L
- 29/41/34 mpg (city/highway/combined)
- 14.5-gallon fuel tank
- 2.5L Dynamic Force 4-cylinder engine
The numbers reveal an interesting dynamic - while the Camry leads in highway efficiency by 3 mpg, the Accord maintains an advantage in city driving. The combined ratings show nearly identical performance, making real-world cost comparisons essential.
--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Real-World Fill-Up Costs Across America
Using AAA's Daily Fuel Gauge Report data from late 2018, we analyzed what owners actually paid at the pump:
| Location | Regular Gas Price | Accord Fill-Up Cost | Camry Fill-Up Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| National Average | $2.56 | $37.89 | $37.12 |
| Alabama (Lowest) | $2.27 | $33.60 | $32.92 |
| Alaska (Highest) | $3.27 | $48.40 | $47.42 |
Regional Price Variations Matter
The data shows that while the national difference was just 77 cents per fill-up favoring the Camry, regional gas price fluctuations created more substantial variations:
$102310 electric 12 mi mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
$42492 Gas 56030 mi
Fair
Deal
0
(5)
$40948 electric 2943 mi
Very Good
Deal
0
(5)
Mercedes Benz EQE
2019 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class SL 450
2024 Honda Prologue
- Northwest saw the sharpest increases - Alaska's prices jumped 18 cents in two weeks
- Hawaii and California maintained consistently high prices above $3.20/gallon
- The Great Lakes region showed unusual volatility with Indiana rising 7 cents while Michigan dropped 8 cents
Beyond Regular Fuel: Premium and Diesel Trends
While both the Accord LX and Camry L use regular unleaded, the 2018 fuel landscape showed other important trends:
- Premium gas averaged $3.09 nationally (up 1¢ from previous week)
- Diesel fuel rose to $2.84 (3¢ increase) due to seasonal demand for heating oil
- Year-over-year regular unleaded prices were up 41¢ from 2017
These broader market movements reminded buyers that fuel costs represent an ongoing expense that can fluctuate significantly based on seasonality and global market conditions.
--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Which Sedan Makes More Financial Sense?
Our analysis reveals several key takeaways for prospective buyers:
For Highway Commuters
The Camry's 41 mpg highway rating gives it a measurable advantage for drivers who spend most of their time on interstates and open roads. Over 15,000 annual miles, this could translate to nearly $100 in annual savings.
For Urban Drivers
The Accord's 30 mpg city rating vs. the Camry's 29 mpg gives Honda a slight edge in stop-and-go traffic. While the difference appears small, it becomes more significant in heavy traffic conditions where turbocharged engines often outperform naturally aspirated ones.
$359180 diesel 12000 mi
Good
Deal
5
(5)
$79999 electric 43 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
$24198 Gas 65824 mi
Good
Deal
0
(5)
Rolls-Royce Cullinan AWD
2023 Jaguar I-PACE
2018 Audi A4 Allroad
For Budget-Conscious Buyers
The minimal difference in fill-up costs (typically under $1 nationally) means fuel economy shouldn't be the deciding factor. Instead, consider:
- Total cost of ownership including maintenance
- Resale value projections
- Available incentives and financing options
The Verdict: Too Close to Call on Fuel Alone
While the 2018 Camry holds a slight edge in highway efficiency and the Accord performs better in city driving, the real-world cost difference is negligible for most drivers. The decision ultimately comes down to:
Choose the Honda Accord If:
- You prioritize urban driving performance
- Prefer turbocharged engine characteristics
- Want slightly more cargo space (16.7 vs 15.1 cu ft)
Choose the Toyota Camry If:
- Highway commuting is your primary use
- You value Toyota's reputation for reliability
- Prefer a more conservative styling approach
Both vehicles represent excellent choices in the midsize sedan segment, with fuel economy that remains competitive even by today's standards. For buyers considering used 2018 models, maintenance history and current condition should outweigh small fuel cost differences.
