Jeep Cherokee Nine-Speed Transmission: In-Depth Review & Real-World Performance

When Chrysler reintroduced the Jeep Cherokee in 2014, one of its most ambitious engineering feats was the inclusion of a cutting-edge nine-speed automatic transmission from ZF Friedrichshafen AG. This technological marvel positioned the Cherokee as a pioneer in its class, boasting more gear ratios than nearly all competitors. At MotorVero, we acquired a four-cylinder, all-wheel-drive Cherokee specifically to evaluate this transmission's real-world performance over thousands of miles.

--FIRST CAR LIST HERE--

The Engineering Behind ZF's Nine-Speed Transmission

ZF's 9HP transmission represents a significant leap in automatic transmission technology, particularly for front-wheel-drive and all-wheel-drive applications. The compact design incorporates four planetary gear sets and six shift elements, achieving nine forward speeds in roughly the same package size as conventional six-speed transmissions. This innovative layout allows for:

• Closer gear ratios: Smaller steps between gears maintain engine rpm in the optimal power band
• Two overdrive gears: 8th and 9th gears are both overdrive ratios for maximum highway efficiency
• Improved launch performance: A low first gear ratio (4.71:1) provides strong initial acceleration

The transmission's complexity did cause significant delays in the Cherokee's launch as engineers worked to refine the powertrain calibration. These early challenges foreshadowed some of the real-world behaviors we would later experience during our long-term test.

Real-World Performance: 14,000-Mile Evaluation

After extensive testing across various driving conditions, we've compiled nine key observations about the Cherokee's nine-speed transmission performance:

1. Surprisingly Natural Driving Experience

Despite its high gear count, the transmission doesn't constantly hunt for gears in normal driving situations. The programming prioritizes gear selection that feels natural to drivers accustomed to five- or six-speed automatics. Sixth through ninth gears are all overdrive ratios, with the top two engaging only during steady highway cruising above 55 mph.

--SECOND CAR LIST HERE--

2. Engine Pairing Matters

The base 2.4-liter Tigershark four-cylinder (184 hp, 171 lb-ft) struggles to compensate for the transmission's occasional ill-timed shifts. The available 3.2-liter Pentastar V-6 (271 hp, 239 lb-ft) provides enough torque to mask many of the gearbox's quirks, making it the preferred pairing for this transmission.

3. Inconsistent Shift Quality

The transmission's behavior varies noticeably day-to-day. Some drives feature buttery-smooth gear changes, while others bring harsh engagements—particularly between first and second gears. This inconsistency became one of our most frequent complaints during ownership.

4. Limited Impact of Software Updates

Multiple visits to the dealership for transmission control module updates yielded only marginal improvements. While some shift points became smoother, fundamental issues with low-speed shift quality persisted even with the latest factory programming.

5. Sport Mode Transformation

The Selec-Terrain system's Sport mode dramatically improves the driving experience by:

• Holding gears longer before upshifts
• Providing more immediate downshifts during acceleration
• Reducing the frequency of awkward gear selections

The trade-off comes in higher engine speeds during casual driving, which impacts both noise levels and fuel economy.

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

6. Persistent 3rd Gear Engagement Issue

One consistent complaint across all software versions was the harsh 2-3 upshift. The transmission often allows second gear to rev excessively before delivering a noticeable jolt into third. This behavior is particularly pronounced during moderate acceleration.

7. Urban Driving Challenges

The transmission's least refined behavior occurs during stop-and-go city driving. The first three gears exhibit the most unpredictable shift patterns, making smooth progress through traffic more difficult than in competitors with conventional six-speed automatics.

8. Highway Cruising Excellence

Once at speed, the transmission becomes nearly transparent in operation. The Cherokee achieves its EPA-estimated 31 mpg highway rating with ease, and the abundance of gear ratios keeps the engine operating quietly at low rpm during steady cruising.

9. Manual Mode Limitations

The Auto Stick manual shifting function proves disappointing with:

• Noticeable delay between lever input and gear change
• Overly aggressive computer intervention
• Restrictive gear selection limits

These limitations make the manual mode less useful than implementations in competitors like the Mazda CX-5 or Toyota RAV4.

--THIRD CAR LIST HERE--

Comparative Analysis: Nine-Speed vs. Conventional Transmissions

When evaluated against traditional six-speed automatics in the compact SUV class, the Cherokee's nine-speed shows both advantages and drawbacks:

Advantages

• Fuel Efficiency: Achieves 1-2 mpg improvement over six-speed designs
• Highway Refinement: Lower cruising rpm enhances comfort on long trips
• Acceleration Flexibility: More gear ratios keep the engine closer to its power peak

Disadvantages

• Shift Quality: More frequent and less predictable gear changes at low speeds
• Complexity: Potential for higher long-term maintenance costs
• Weight: Approximately 15-20 lbs heavier than comparable six-speed units

Long-Term Reliability Considerations

While our test period didn't reveal any mechanical failures, the transmission's complexity raises questions about long-term durability. Several factors warrant consideration:

• Fluid Service Requirements: Uses specialized ATF with 60,000-mile change intervals
• Mechatronic Unit: The transmission's electronic control module is integrated into the gearbox
• Clutch Pack Design: Incorporates five multi-plate clutches and one brake band

Proper maintenance appears crucial for long-term reliability, with fluid condition playing a particularly important role in shift quality and component longevity.

--SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Owner Impressions vs. Professional Reviews

Analysis of owner forums and professional reviews reveals a consensus about the nine-speed transmission:

• Professional Reviews: Often note the transmission's quirks but emphasize its technical achievement
• Owner Impressions: Tend to focus more on daily driving frustrations with shift quality
• Common Complaints: Low-speed shift harshness and unpredictable behavior top the list

This disparity suggests that while the transmission represents an engineering milestone, its real-world implementation may not fully satisfy all drivers.

--FORTH CAR LIST HERE--

Final Verdict: Innovation vs. Execution

The Jeep Cherokee's nine-speed transmission represents an impressive technological achievement that delivers measurable benefits in fuel efficiency and highway refinement. However, its inconsistent low-speed behavior and shift quality issues prevent it from setting a new benchmark in the segment.

For buyers considering a Cherokee, we recommend:

• Opting for the V-6 engine to better complement the transmission's characteristics
• Using Sport mode for urban driving to improve shift quality
• Ensuring all available software updates are applied
• Test driving extensively to evaluate personal tolerance for the transmission's quirks

While not without flaws, the nine-speed transmission remains an intriguing option for buyers prioritizing highway efficiency and technological innovation in their SUV. As with any advanced automotive technology, thorough evaluation and realistic expectations are key to ownership satisfaction.

--THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--