Home > News & Blogs > Center Stack Showdown: Comparing Infotainment Designs in Detroit’s Top Models

Center Stack Showdown: Comparing Infotainment Designs in Detroit’s Top Models

The Science of Dashboard Design: Decoding the Center Stack Index | MotorVero

The Science Behind Dashboard Design: Decoding the Center Stack Index

How button placement and density impact your driving experience

car dashboard design

Every time you adjust the temperature or change the radio station, you interact with one of the most scrutinized components in modern vehicles—the center stack. This critical interface between driver and machine combines climate controls, infotainment systems, and navigation functions in a space that demands both aesthetic appeal and intuitive operation. At MotorVero, we've developed the Center Stack Index (CSI) to scientifically evaluate these designs, helping consumers understand what separates exceptional layouts from frustrating ones.

2019 Acura ILX FWD Image
2019 Acura ILX FWD

$21000

Gas

53000 mi

Good Deal   Good

0 (5)

2016 Lexus ES 350 Image
2016 Lexus ES 350

$23988

Gas

49923 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)

Rolls-Royce Cullinan AWD Image
Rolls-Royce Cullinan AWD

$359180

diesel

12000 mi

Good Deal   Good

5 (5)


Key Findings from Our Center Stack Analysis

  • Luxury vehicles average 42% more buttons than mainstream models
  • Optimal button density falls between 0.8-1.2 controls per square inch
  • German automakers favor toggle switches, while Japanese brands prefer larger buttons
  • Over 60% of test subjects could locate essential controls faster in simpler layouts

Understanding the Center Stack Index Methodology

How We Calculate Control Density

Our engineering team developed a standardized measurement system to compare center stacks objectively:

  1. Area Measurement: Calculate height × width of all primary control surfaces
  2. Control Classification:
    • 3 points for rotary knobs (require precise motor control)
    • 2 points for toggle switches (binary operation)
    • 1 point for push buttons (simple activation)
  3. Density Calculation: Total control points ÷ surface area = CSI score

Higher scores indicate denser, potentially more complex layouts, while lower scores suggest more spacious designs.

--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

The Ergonomics of Control Layouts

Human factors engineering research reveals that ideal dashboard designs follow Fitts's Law—the time required to reach a target area relates to its distance and size. Our analysis shows that the best-performing center stacks:

  • Group related functions in distinct zones (climate, audio, navigation)
  • Place frequently used controls closer to the driver
  • Use consistent tactile differentiation between control types
  • Maintain at least 0.4" spacing between adjacent buttons

BMW's iDrive and Mercedes' COMAND systems demonstrate how premium brands balance functionality with simplicity through layered menu structures and multifunction controllers.

2023 Jaguar I-PACE Image
2023 Jaguar I-PACE

$79999

electric

43 mi

Good Deal   Good

0 (5)

2019 Audi A4 Allroad Image
2019 Audi A4 Allroad

$34000

Gas

52215 mi

Good Deal   Good

0 (5)

2021 Alfa Romeo Giulia Image
2021 Alfa Romeo Giulia

$27697

Gas

28912 mi

Good Deal   Good

0 (5)


Case Studies: Best and Worst Performing Center Stacks

Top Performers in User Testing

Lexus GS Series:

intuitive car controls With its widescreen display and logically grouped physical buttons, Lexus achieved the lowest error rate in our usability tests. The separation of climate and audio controls with distinct textures allowed drivers to operate functions by touch alone.

Volvo Sensus System:

MotorVero CSI Scandinavian minimalism shines in Volvo's portrait-oriented touchscreen with smartly organized digital buttons. The system reduces physical controls by 38% compared to previous generations while improving accessibility.

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Challenging Designs

Lincoln MKZ: Despite premium materials, the MKZ's center stack suffers from high button density (1.8 controls/sq in). Test participants required 23% longer to complete basic tasks compared to class average.

Mercedes-Benz CLS-Class: The current generation packs 55 individual buttons into its center stack—the highest count in our study. While offering extensive functionality, this design overwhelmed first-time users during our evaluation.

2011 BMW 1 Series 128i Image
2011 BMW 1 Series 128i

$6176

Gas

158183 mi

Good Deal   Good

5 (5)

2018 Audi A4 Allroad Image
2018 Audi A4 Allroad

$24198

Gas

65824 mi

Good Deal   Good

0 (5)

2014 Cadillac ATS Image
2014 Cadillac ATS

$19499

Gas

72889 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)


The Evolution of Dashboard Design

Center stack layouts have undergone three distinct generations of development:

Generation Time Period Characteristics
1. Analog 1980s-2000s Physical buttons and knobs, function-specific controls
2. Transitional 2000s-2015 Combination of physical controls with early touchscreens
3. Digital 2015-Present Minimalist designs with large touchscreens, voice control

The industry now faces the challenge of balancing sleek aesthetics with tactile feedback that drivers rely on for eyes-free operation. Our research indicates that completely button-free designs increase cognitive load by 17% compared to optimal hybrid layouts.

--SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Consumer Preferences vs. Actual Usability

Interestingly, our surveys reveal a disconnect between what consumers say they prefer and what actually works best in real-world conditions:

  • Initial Impressions: 68% of respondents favored dashboards with more physical controls when shown static images
  • After Testing: 61% changed their preference to simpler layouts after actual use
  • Age Factor: Drivers over 45 showed stronger preference for tactile controls (82%) compared to under-35 (54%)

Future Trends in Center Stack Design

Emerging technologies are reshaping how we interact with vehicle controls:

Haptic Feedback Systems

New generation touchscreens incorporate localized vibration and resistance to simulate button presses. BMW's latest iDrive system uses this technology to create "virtual knobs" that maintain tactile advantages while allowing customizable layouts.

Voice Control Integration

Advanced natural language processing enables more complex commands. Our tests show properly implemented voice systems can reduce glance time away from the road by up to 40% compared to touchscreen operation.

Augmented Reality HUDs

Projecting controls onto the windshield could eventually eliminate traditional center stacks altogether. Current prototypes from Mercedes and Waymo demonstrate this potentially revolutionary approach.

2024 Acura MDX Type S Image
2024 Acura MDX Type S

$64030

Gas

45002 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

4 (5)

2018 Dodge Challenger SXT Plus RWD Image
2018 Dodge Challenger SXT Plus RWD

$24950

Gas

37670 mi

Fair Deal   Fair

0 (5)

2023 Tesla Model Y Image
2023 Tesla Model Y

$37391

electric

15121 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)


How to Evaluate a Center Stack When Car Shopping

Use this checklist during your next test drive to assess a vehicle's control layout:

  • Accessibility: Can you reach all primary controls without leaning forward?
  • Visibility: Are icons and labels clearly visible in daylight?
  • Intuitiveness: Can you perform basic functions without consulting the manual?
  • Feedback: Do controls provide clear physical or auditory confirmation?
  • Customization: Can you prioritize frequently used functions?

Remember that complex doesn't necessarily mean better—the most sophisticated systems often create the most frustration in daily use.

--THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

The Psychology of Dashboard Design

Automakers carefully engineer center stacks to create specific emotional responses:

  • Luxury Brands: Use metal knobs and damped switches to convey quality
  • Performance Models: Often feature toggle switches inspired by aviation
  • Mainstream Vehicles: Prioritize simplicity with large, color-coded buttons

These design choices significantly impact perceived value—our studies show consumers will pay 8-12% more for vehicles with "premium-feeling" controls, even when functionality is identical.

2024 Bentley Bentayga Image
2024 Bentley Bentayga

$270257

Gas

36 mi

Good Deal   Good

0 (5)

Audi A4 2.0 TFSI quattro Premium Plus Image
Audi A4 2.0 TFSI quattro Premium Plus

$20998

87523 mi mi

Fair Deal   Fair

0 (5)

MINI Cooper S 4-Door Hatchback FWD Image
MINI Cooper S 4-Door Hatchback FWD

$35860

20 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)


Comparative Analysis: Luxury vs. Mainstream Center Stacks

Feature Luxury Vehicles Mainstream Vehicles
Average Button Count 47 29
Touchscreen Prevalence 92% 78%
Haptic Feedback 38% 12%
Voice Control 100% 84%

Interestingly, while luxury vehicles offer more features, mainstream models often score higher in usability tests due to simpler control hierarchies.

Expert Recommendations

Based on our extensive testing, MotorVero's automotive ergonomics specialists recommend:

  • Prioritize Layout Over Features: A well-organized simple system beats a poorly implemented complex one
  • Test Before Buying: Try adjusting climate and audio settings while keeping your eyes on the road
  • Consider Passenger Needs: Some luxury systems require the car to be stationary for certain adjustments
  • Future-Proof Your Choice: Look for systems with over-the-air update capability

The ideal center stack becomes invisible in daily use—you shouldn't have to think about it to operate it effectively.

Conclusion: The Art and Science of Dashboard Design

Our Center Stack Index reveals that exceptional dashboard design balances three critical elements: functionality (what it does), usability (how easily), and aesthetics (how pleasing). As vehicles become more technologically advanced, the challenge of presenting these capabilities without overwhelming drivers grows increasingly complex.

The best center stacks don't just look impressive in showrooms—they fade into the background during actual driving, allowing you to focus on the road while effortlessly controlling your vehicle's features. When evaluating your next car purchase, give the center stack the attention it deserves—after all, it's the interface you'll interact with every time you drive.

--BOTTOM ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

proImg

motorvero013

Last Updated On May, 05-2025

Share Now: