Home > News & Blogs > 2019 BMW X5 Review: 9 Pros and 4 Cons You Should Know

2019 BMW X5 Review: 9 Pros and 4 Cons You Should Know

BMW X5 Review: Luxury SUV Strengths and Weaknesses | MotorVero

BMW X5 Review: The Benchmark Luxury SUV That Faces Stiff Competition

BMW X5 review

The BMW X5 created the luxury performance SUV segment two decad

es ago, but does this third-generation model still lead the pack against rivals like the Mercedes-Benz GLE and Audi Q7? We analyze every aspect.

The Evolution of BMW's Flagship SUV

When BMW introduced the original X5 (E53) in 1999, it pioneered an entirely new vehicle category - the sports activity vehicle (SAV). This groundbreaking approach prioritized on-road dynamics over traditional SUV ruggedness, creating a template that competitors would follow for years.

Current Generation Overview

The G05-generation X5 debuted with:

  • Larger dimensions than previous models (194.3" length, 74.9" width)
  • New CLAR modular platform shared with 7 Series sedans
  • Standard xDrive all-wheel drive system
  • Available mild-hybrid powertrains
  • Optional Off-Road Package with air suspension

2011 BMW 1 Series 128i Image
2011 BMW 1 Series 128i

$6176

Gas

158183 mi

Fair Deal   Fair

0 (5)

2016 Buick Cascada Image
2016 Buick Cascada

$12243

Gas

77700 mi

Good Deal   Good

1 (5)

2024 Chrysler Pacifica Image
2024 Chrysler Pacifica

$49092

Gas

0 mi

Very Good Deal   Very Good

0 (5)


BMW X5 Performance and Driving Dynamics

xDrive40i Powertrain

3.0L Turbo I6

335 HP / 330 LB-FT

0-60: 5.3s

xDrive50i Powertrain

4.4L Twin-Turbo V8

456 HP / 479 LB-FT

0-60: 4.6s

M50i Performance

4.4L Twin-Turbo V8

523 HP / 553 LB-FT

0-60: 4.1s

While the X5's powertrains deliver segment-leading acceleration, the driving experience has drawn mixed reactions from enthusiasts. The electric power steering system, while precise, lacks the feedback that characterized earlier BMW models. This represents a significant departure from the brand's "Ultimate Driving Machine" heritage.

Detailed Strengths and Weaknesses

What We Love About the BMW X5

  • Timeless Design Language: The X5 maintains BMW's signature styling cues while evolving with contemporary trends. The enlarged kidney grille (controversial to some) and laser headlights create a distinctive presence.
  • Powertrain Excellence: BMW's B58 3.0L turbocharged inline-six is a masterpiece of smooth power delivery and efficiency, earning Ward's 10 Best Engines recognition multiple times.
  • Interior Craftsmanship: Vernasca leather, real metal trim, and optional glass controls create an ambiance that rivals luxury sedans. The optional Bowers & Wilkins Diamond surround sound system sets new benchmarks.
  • Advanced Safety: Standard features include forward collision warning with automatic emergency braking, lane departure warning, and blind spot monitoring. The optional Driving Assistance Professional Package adds highway assistant capabilities.
  • Technology Integration: The iDrive 7.0 system remains one of the most intuitive interfaces, with crisp graphics and logical menu structures despite the added complexity of modern vehicle functions.
  • --TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Areas Needing Improvement

  • Steering Feedback: The electrically assisted system filters out too much road feel, diminishing driver engagement compared to Porsche Cayenne or Alfa Romeo Stelvio.
  • Ergonomic Quirks: The split tailgate design, while distinctive, proves less practical than conventional liftgates for loading bulky items.
  • Gesture Control Limitations: While innovative, the system's reduced functionality compared to 7 Series models feels like a half-implemented feature rather than a true convenience.
  • Third-Row Compromises: The optional rear seats offer minimal legroom (just 29.9 inches) suitable only for children, putting the X5 at a disadvantage against true three-row luxury SUVs.
  • Premium Pricing: With options easily pushing the price beyond $80,000, the X5 faces tough competition from vehicles offering more standard features or greater exclusivity.

Competitive Landscape: How the X5 Stacks Up

When cross-shopping luxury midsize SUVs, consider these key competitors:

Mercedes-Benz GLE-Class

BMW vs Mercedes GLE

★★★★☆

Advantages: More luxurious standard interior, superior MBUX infotainment, available E-Active Body Control

Disadvantages: Less engaging to drive, higher base price

Audi Q7

luxury SUV comparison

★★★★☆

Advantages: Standard third row, superior Quattro all-wheel drive, better value proposition

Disadvantages: Conservative styling, less powerful base engine

Porsche Cayenne

best mid-size SUV


★★★★★

Advantages: Superior driving dynamics, higher-performance variants, prestigious badge

Disadvantages: Significantly more expensive, smaller cargo area

2025 BMW i4 xDrive40 Image
2025 BMW i4 xDrive40

$66295

electric

9 mi

Fair Deal   Fair

0 (5)

2017 Acura ILX Image
2017 Acura ILX

$64900

Gas

4600 mi

Good Deal   Good

0 (5)

2018 Acura ILX Image
2018 Acura ILX

$64030

Gas

45002 mi

Good Deal   Good

4 (5)


Ownership Considerations

Fuel Efficiency Ratings

  • xDrive40i: 21 mpg city / 26 mpg highway / 23 mpg combined
  • xDrive50i: 17 mpg city / 22 mpg highway / 19 mpg combined
  • M50i: 16 mpg city / 22 mpg highway / 18 mpg combined

Maintenance Costs

BMW offers included scheduled maintenance for 3 years/36,000 miles, but out-of-warranty repairs can be expensive. Independent shops report common issues with:

  • Cooling system components
  • Electronic gremlins in advanced driver aids
  • Air suspension components (if equipped)

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--


Final Verdict

The BMW X5 remains one of the most complete packages in the luxury midsize SUV segment, offering a compelling blend of performance, technology, and prestige. While it no longer dominates dynamically as it once did, the X5 compensates with class-leading powertrains and a meticulously crafted interior. For buyers prioritizing driving enjoyment over absolute luxury, the Porsche Cayenne may be worth the premium, while those seeking maximum comfort might prefer the Mercedes GLE. However, as an all-around performer with strong resale value and brand cachet, the X5 continues to set standards that others follow.

proImg

motorverorachael

Last Updated On May, 31-2025

Share Now: