Top 3-Row SUVs Compared: Honda Pilot, Toyota Highlander, Chevrolet Traverse & Volkswagen Atlas

Introduction: Why 3-Row SUVs Dominate the Family Market

Three-row SUVs have become a staple in modern families' driveways, offering a combination of spaciousness, comfort, and technology that minivans once cornered the market on. With newer models pushing the envelope on efficiency, safety, and performance, MotorVero set out to compare four of the most competitive 3-row SUVs in this category: the Honda Pilot, Toyota Highlander, Chevrolet Traverse, and Volkswagen Atlas. This comprehensive guide explores which SUV is the most compelling choice for growing families and adventure seekers alike.

2023 Jaguar I-PACE

$79999

electric

43 mi

Good Deal  

0 (5)

Chrysler Pacifica Touring L FWD

$19375

Gas

93184 mi

Good Deal  

0 (5)

2024 Tesla Cybertruck

$134524

electric

445 mi

Very Good Deal  

0 (5)

See More

Honda Pilot: A Solid All-Rounder With Some Flaws

Previously crowned the top pick in the 3-row SUV category, the Honda Pilot still impresses with its roomy interior, practical storage solutions, and clever features like a one-touch system for third-row access. However, it now shows its age compared to newer rivals. Despite its spacious layout and reputation for reliability, drawbacks like its underwhelming nine-speed automatic transmission and dated infotainment system prevent it from clinching the top spot again.

• Pros: Roomy cabin, excellent third-row access, strong resale value
• Cons: Clunky transmission, outdated multimedia system
• --TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
  

Toyota Highlander: Premium Feel, But Tight on Space

The Toyota Highlander continues to deliver strong performance and upscale features, thanks to a recent engine upgrade and exterior redesign. While its dashboard includes a thoughtful device tray for smartphones and a generally premium feel inside, the Highlander falls short in cabin space and third-row accessibility. It remains a reliable, tech-savvy SUV but lacks the scale to accommodate larger families comfortably.

• Pros: Quality interior finishes, updated drivetrain, innovative dash design
• Cons: Cramped third row, small cargo capacity, dated infotainment interface
• 

  2014 Cadillac ATS

  $19499

  Gas

  72889 mi

  Very Good Deal  

  0 (5)

  

  Nissan Note 1.2E

  $15650

  electric

  73215 mi

  Very Good Deal  

  0 (5)

  

  2014 Toyota 4Runner

  $20899

  Gas

  140789 mi

  Good Deal  

  0 (5)

  See More
  
  

Chevrolet Traverse: Comfort Meets Capability

The Chevrolet Traverse underwent a full redesign, emerging as one of the most balanced choices in the 3-row SUV segment. It provides an expansive interior without feeling oversized from the driver’s perspective. The cabin is impressively quiet, and the ride quality rivals luxury SUVs. Ideal for families who value comfort, tech, and ride refinement, the Traverse stands tall among its peers.

• Pros: Smooth ride, spacious interior, quiet cabin, responsive infotainment
• Cons: Less fuel-efficient, conservative styling
• --FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
  

Volkswagen Atlas: The New Benchmark

The Volkswagen Atlas emerged as the standout SUV in this comparison. It combines straightforward functionality with user-friendly technology, a roomy third row that even adults can comfortably use, and sharp, composed handling. The Atlas strikes a nearly perfect balance of performance, space, and simplicity, making it the go-to option for families who need flexibility without compromise.

• Pros: Class-leading third-row space, intuitive multimedia system, smooth 8-speed transmission
• Cons: Subtle styling, slightly firm ride

Interior Space and Versatility: Who Delivers the Most?

When evaluating 3-row SUVs, passenger and cargo space are critical. The Atlas offers class-leading third-row room, while the Traverse follows closely. The Pilot and Highlander, although practical, fall short in maximizing usable space. The Atlas and Traverse are best suited for larger families or frequent carpooling, offering more flexible storage and legroom across all three rows.

2014 Cadillac ATS

$19499

Gas

72889 mi

Very Good Deal  

0 (5)

Nissan Note 1.2E

$15650

electric

73215 mi

Very Good Deal  

0 (5)

2014 Toyota 4Runner

$20899

Gas

140789 mi

Good Deal  

0 (5)

See More

Technology and Infotainment: Usability Over Flash

Usability and intuitiveness set the Volkswagen Atlas apart. Its infotainment system was the clear favorite among reviewers for its responsiveness and ease of use. The Traverse and Highlander also offer solid tech, while the Pilot's interface continues to feel dated. For tech-savvy drivers, Atlas leads the pack with minimal distraction and maximum functionality.

Ride Quality and Driving Experience

Ride comfort is essential for family travel, and here the Traverse excels with a smooth, composed demeanor. The Atlas also impresses with direct steering and stable cornering. The Pilot delivers a reliable, if not overly engaging ride, while the Highlander can feel cramped and slightly disconnected due to its compact design.

Fuel Efficiency and Powertrains

Fuel economy is a deciding factor for many SUV buyers. While none of the contenders are outright fuel misers, the Highlander’s updated V6 provides respectable mileage. The Atlas and Traverse prioritize power and space, which results in slightly lower efficiency. The Pilot’s transmission struggles diminish its overall fuel economy performance.

--SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Family-Focused Features That Matter

Features like rear-seat climate controls, USB ports, second-row captain’s chairs, and easy access to the third row are must-haves for family buyers. All four SUVs offer various configurations, but the Atlas and Traverse are particularly well-equipped with child-friendly conveniences, rear visibility systems, and ample cupholders. The Pilot also shines with its built-in CabinTalk system, useful for communicating with third-row passengers.

Safety Ratings and Driver Assistance Technology

All four SUVs perform well in safety tests, but standout technologies vary. The Atlas and Traverse come loaded with advanced driver assistance features, while the Highlander includes Toyota Safety Sense across all trims. The Pilot also includes key safety tech but lacks the refinement and integration of its competitors.

--FOURTH CAR LIST HERE--

Which SUV is Right for You?

Choosing the right 3-row SUV depends on individual needs. The Volkswagen Atlas stands out as the best all-around option, excelling in space, usability, and comfort. The Chevrolet Traverse is ideal for those who want luxury-like comfort and a quiet cabin. The Honda Pilot remains a safe and reliable bet with practical features. Finally, the Toyota Highlander is best suited for smaller families prioritizing premium touches and reliability.

Final Verdict: The Winner is Clear

After evaluating these top contenders, the Volkswagen Atlas takes the crown. Its combination of usable space, technology, and performance sets a new standard for 3-row SUVs. Whether you're upgrading your family vehicle or shopping for a road-trip-ready ride, the Atlas provides a complete package that’s hard to beat.

--THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--