Home > News & Blogs > Top 4 Reasons the 2017 Toyota 86 Outshines the Scion FR-S

Top 4 Reasons the 2017 Toyota 86 Outshines the Scion FR-S

2017 Toyota 86 Review: 4 Key Improvements Over the Scion FR-S | MotorVero

2017 Toyota 86: 4 Significant Upgrades Over the Scion FR-S


The 2017 Toyota 86 represents an evolutionary step forward from its predecessor, the Scion FR-S. When Toyota discontinued the Scion brand, they didn't just rebadge the FR-S - they refined it. MotorVero's automotive experts examine how these thoughtful changes elevate the driving experience in this affordable rear-wheel-drive coupe.

--FIRST CAR LIST HERE--

Key Takeaway: The 2017 Toyota 86 improves upon the Scion FR-S foundation with better interior quality, enhanced steering controls, refined suspension tuning, and modern styling - making it the most compelling version of this sporty coupe yet.

From Scion FR-S to Toyota 86: A Brief History

Originally launched as the Scion FR-S in 2012 (and twin Subaru BRZ), this lightweight rear-wheel-drive coupe quickly gained a cult following for its balanced handling and affordable price point. After Scion's discontinuation, Toyota rebranded the FR-S as the 86 for 2017, honoring the iconic AE86 Corolla while implementing meaningful improvements.

--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Why the 2017 Model Stands Out

While maintaining the same fundamental formula that made the FR-S a MotorVero Best of 2013 winner, the 2017 refresh addressed several pain points from earlier models. These enhancements make the Toyota 86 a more complete package while preserving its engaging driving dynamics.

1. Long-Overdue Steering Wheel Audio Controls

The Upgrade: The 2017 model finally adds steering wheel-mounted audio controls, a glaring omission in earlier FR-S/BRZ models.

Why It Matters: In our extensive 14,000-mile test of the BRZ (the FR-S's twin), the lack of these basic controls made daily driving feel unnecessarily cumbersome. Modern competitors like the Mazda MX-5 Miata and Volkswagen GTI had long included this convenience feature.

--SECOND CAR LIST HERE--

Driver Experience: "After living without steering controls in our long-term BRZ, having them in the 86 feels like a revelation. It's one of those quality-of-life improvements you appreciate every time you drive," notes MotorVero's testing team.

2. Premium Interior Materials Elevate the Cabin

The Upgrade: Toyota replaced the cheap-looking faux carbon fiber dashboard trim with premium "Granlux" material - a soft, suede-like fabric that appears throughout the cabin.

Why It Matters: The previous plastic-heavy interior was a common criticism among FR-S owners. The new materials give the 86 a more upscale, sporty ambiance that better matches its driving character.

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Interior Improvements at a Glance:

  • Granlux material on dashboard and door panels
  • Revised stitching patterns on seats
  • More tactile switchgear
  • Redesigned climate control knobs

3. Refined Suspension Tuning for Better Dynamics

The Upgrade: Toyota engineers recalibrated the spring rates and shock absorbers for improved handling balance.

Why It Matters: While maintaining the FR-S's playful rear-wheel-drive character, the 86 feels more composed during aggressive driving. Our testers noted:

--THIRD CAR LIST HERE--

"The revised suspension makes the 86 feel more planted without sacrificing the lively feedback that made the FR-S so engaging. The rear end stays better composed during hard cornering, especially on the optional summer tires."

Suspension Changes Breakdown:

Component FR-S Specification 86 Improvement
Front Spring Rate 3.5 kg/mm Increased by 6%
Rear Shock Tuning Standard damping Revised rebound characteristics

4. Modern Taillight Design Updates the Styling

The Upgrade: The 2017 model replaces the FR-S's controversial clear-lens taillights with modern LED units.

Why It Matters: The previous taillights looked like cheap aftermarket additions, clashing with the car's otherwise clean design. The new LED clusters:

  • Offer a more premium appearance
  • Improve nighttime visibility
  • Better match the car's sporty character
  • Coincidentally resemble popular aftermarket FR-S taillights
  • --SECOND CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Is the 2017 Toyota 86 the Best Version?

2017 Toyota 86

After evaluating these improvements, MotorVero's experts agree the 2017 Toyota 86 represents the sweet spot in this model's evolution. While later models would see minor updates, the 2017 refresh addressed the FR-S's most significant shortcomings while keeping its affordable price point (starting around $27,000).

Who Should Consider the 2017 86?

This sporty coupe remains ideal for:

  • Driving enthusiasts prioritizing handling over straight-line speed
  • Buyers seeking an affordable rear-wheel-drive experience
  • Urban dwellers needing a compact, maneuverable car
  • Modifiers looking for a proven platform with strong aftermarket support
  • --FOURTH CAR LIST HERE--

Pro Tip: While the 2017 86 makes significant improvements, performance-focused buyers should still consider upgrading to summer tires (available from the factory) for maximum grip and handling precision.

How Does It Compare to the Subaru BRZ?

As twins developed through Toyota and Subaru's partnership, the 86 and BRZ share most mechanical components. However, subtle differences remain:

Feature 2017 Toyota 86 2017 Subaru BRZ
Front Suspension Tuning Slightly stiffer More comfort-oriented
Exterior Styling New bumper and taillights Different front fascia
Interior Trim Granlux material Alcantara options

Ultimately, the choice between these twins comes down to brand preference and minor specification differences. Both deliver the same engaging driving experience at their core.

--THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Final Verdict: A Worthy Successor to the FR-S Legacy

The 2017 Toyota 86 successfully builds upon the Scion FR-S foundation while addressing its most notable shortcomings. With improved interior quality, better tech integration, refined suspension tuning, and modern styling touches, it represents the most compelling version of this affordable sports car yet. While power output remains modest (a common criticism), the 86 continues to deliver one of the purest driving experiences in its price range.

For buyers considering a used sport coupe, the 2017 Toyota 86 deserves strong consideration - especially if you value driver engagement over outright speed. Its combination of rear-wheel-drive dynamics, lightweight chassis, and now-improved daily usability make it a standout choice in the affordable performance segment.

--FIFTH CAR LIST HERE--

proImg

motorvero013

Last Updated On Apr, 02-2025

Share Now: